Stage 8: Management systems and auditing · topic 32 of 50

Internal audit practice and corrective action

An internal audit checks that what a site says it does is what happens. You will plan one, gather evidence, write and grade findings, find root causes and verify that the fixes worked.

  • Core
  • Intermediate
  • about 16 hours

Part of the EHS officer roadmap: how to become one and what to learn

Written by the GreenHired editorial teamSources last checked 20 November 2026How we research roadmaps

An internal audit has three moves: decide what you will test and against what (often the requirements of a system such as ISO 45001 and ISO 14001), collect evidence a stranger could trace, then write findings in a form the process owner can act on. Grading, root cause and the closing meeting all depend on the quality of the evidence, so spend your time there, not on polishing the checklist.

Auditing permit to work: sample, evidence, finding, cause

An internal auditor is asked to audit permit to work at a mid-size plant. The scope is hot work and confined space permits issued last quarter, the criteria are the site’s own permit procedure, and the people to see are one permit issuer, two contractors and one operator. The sample is ten permits spread across weeks, trades and the night shift, not just the tidy ones from last week.

Three permits (numbers 0412, 0419 and 0433) have no isolation reference. A contractor cannot say who signed the handback, and on the walkthrough a permit is still displayed for a job finished two days earlier. The finding is written as criterion, evidence and gap: the procedure says an isolation reference is recorded before work starts; the three permits above have none; the check is not being made.

Grading is next. There are three failures against one requirement, and one certification body says several minors against one requirement can add up to a major. An internal audit, though, grades against the site’s own written definitions, so the auditor applies those and records why. Then the cause: issuers sign with the isolation “pending” because isolation certificates arrive late, and the form lets them, so the cause is the form and the workflow, not the three issuers.

The action is to make the isolation line mandatory on the form and brief the issuers. The facts are agreed at the closing meeting, and the fix is verified by pulling the next sample of permits two months later. The scenario is invented, the permit numbers are made up and none of it is advice for a real site.

Closing a finding so it stays closed

Give every action an owner and a date, and verify it from evidence: a record, a changed form, a completed inspection. For a serious finding, look again later. A finding that keeps coming back means the cause was not the one you fixed, so go deeper with root cause analysis. Keep your plans, findings and reports from practice audits and add them to your evidence portfolio.

HSE says auditors and certifiers should show competence to a recognised standard, and its page names ISO 19011:2011 and the ISO 17021 series. That 2011 edition is out of date: an ASCB bulletin (as read on 20 November 2026) says ISO 19011:2026 replaced the 2018 edition in May 2026, with no transition period. Those texts are paid, so read the licensed current edition if you plan to audit formally, and see auditor training routes for the courses.

What you will learn

  • How to plan an audit: scope, criteria, schedule, checklist and the people you need to see.
  • How to gather evidence by interview, observation and record review, and how sampling shapes what you can conclude.
  • How certification bodies grade findings (major and minor nonconformities, opportunities for improvement) and how to write a clear finding.
  • How to look for the cause behind a finding, not only the symptom.
  • How to report, hold a closing meeting and verify that corrective actions worked.

The parts of this topic

Audit plan, scope and checklistabout 2 hours

Decide what you audit, against which criteria, who you will see and what evidence you will look for, before you arrive.

A plan states scope, criteria (the standard, procedure or law), dates, people and areas. EPA advises that when you set the scope you consider what has changed since the last audit: staff, activities, equipment, compliance obligations, procedures and monitoring data. OSHA offers a free Safety and Health Program Audit Tool, and certification bodies publish free gap analysis checklists. A scope might be the contractor control process, audited using the permit register. Add questions that ask someone to show you, because yes/no questions alone never test how work is actually done.

Sampling and multi-site scopeabout 2 hours

You cannot check everything; choose samples that let you conclude something fair about the system.

Multi-site certification uses a square-root rule, as one certification body explains it: with 25 sites in scope at least five are audited in an initial audit, and over a three-year cycle all sites are normally visited at least once. Inside a site the same idea applies to records and people: sample across shifts, contractors and activities rather than the easy ones. For permits, that could be ten chosen across different weeks and trades. Sampling only the latest records or the best-run area gives false comfort.

Evidence, interviews and walkthroughsabout 2 hours

Use interviews, observation and records together, and keep to what you saw and read.

EPA says an internal EMS audit is performed by an objective and impartial party who carries out interviews and facility walkthroughs to see whether the system conforms to the organisation's own policies and procedures. Good evidence is specific and traceable: a record number, a date, a place, a person's role. Example: a worker is asked to show how they would respond to a spill and the kit is found empty. Leading questions, or interviews with managers only, return what the system should be doing, not what is being done.

Grading findingsabout 2 hours

Know how certification audits distinguish major and minor nonconformities and opportunities for improvement.

A certification body's report identifies minor nonconformities, major nonconformities and opportunities for improvement. It defines a major nonconformity as the total breakdown of a system, meaning a requirement of the standard is not met, and says a number of minors against one requirement can add up to a major; majors must be fixed before certification can be recommended. Internal audits may use simpler grades: one missed inspection might be minor and a missing permit system major. Write each grade's definition down so that two auditors do not rate the same finding differently.

Writing nonconformities and corrective actionsabout 2 hours

A finding states the requirement, the evidence and the gap; the corrective action fixes the cause as well as the case.

A usable finding has three parts: the criterion that applies, the evidence found and how it fails the criterion. EPA's guidance says to correct the nonconformance and mitigate impacts, identify the cause, document a corrective action plan and fix the issue, with examples such as recyclables found in landfill-bound trash traced to unclear signage. In a hazardous waste check, containers missing start dates might be traced to an untrained contractor and fixed by changing the contract. Write the finding about the gap, not the person: blaming someone invites argument, not action.

Finding the root cause behind a findingabout 2 hours

Ask why repeatedly until you reach a management-system cause, and fix that.

OSHA's investigation guide advises asking why repeatedly: if a rule was not followed, why not, and what pressure or design made it hard? The same technique applies to audit findings, where the answer is often training, supervision, resources, design or priorities. Example: a missed inspection turns out to have had no owner after a reorganisation. Retraining the person involved closes the finding on paper, but an underlying cause such as an unrealistic schedule will recreate it.

Audit report and closing meetingabout 2 hours

Hold a short closing meeting, agree the findings factually and issue a report people can act on.

At the end of a Stage 2 audit, one certification body says, the auditor holds a closing meeting to review the audit and discuss nonconformities and corrective action, and a written report follows with observations and findings. Internal audits follow the same pattern: findings agreed as factual, a short report, clear priorities and dates. A finding that appears for the first time in the written report, never discussed, costs you the owner's trust, so have the process owner agree the evidence in the meeting before you leave.

Follow-up and verification of actionsabout 2 hours

Actions are closed when the change is verified, not when someone says it is done.

OSHA's programme evaluation element asks employers to verify that the programme is implemented and operating and to correct shortcomings, using leading and lagging indicators. Follow-up means checking evidence of the change and, for serious findings, checking again later that it still works. If actions turn green when the owner sends an email, the tracker measures replies, not fixes. A new inspection schedule, for instance, is verified by looking at completed inspection records two months on.

Preparing for a third-party auditabout 2 hours

Be ready for a certification or customer audit with a current system, records and people who can explain their work.

A certification body's seven steps to ISO 45001 include carrying out an internal audit before certification, and it says it can perform a pre-assessment audit for you. Preparing means current records, an up-to-date legal register, trained people who can describe their tasks and open actions with realistic dates. Example: a mock audit a month before, using the auditor's likely questions. A rush of paperwork the week before leaves day-to-day practice unchanged, and the audit looks at practice.

Practice task

Audit one real process, for example waste handling or permit to work, at a workplace you can access or using a sample procedure. Produce a one-page audit plan, a checklist, three findings written with criterion, evidence and the gap, a root cause note for one, and a short report.

Skills you build

Audit planningEvidence gathering and interviewingWriting nonconformitiesCorrective action follow-upAudit reporting

Resources for this topic

Every source here is free. Each link opens the provider's own site in a new tab.

Back to the whole roadmap

Live jobs

Live Environmental, health and safety (EHS) officer jobs

Roles whose title matches this career path.

All Environmental Health & Safety jobs

Spot a problem with this topic?

Tell us what is wrong, missing or unclear here. Your note is attached to this topic.

Notes are sent from this page with JavaScript on. Without it, write to us on the contact page.