Stage 6: Topic depth: materiality, E, S, G · topic 22 of 47

Single and double materiality assessments

A materiality assessment decides which sustainability topics a company reports and records why. You will run one, score impacts and risks against your own thresholds, and write the method note an assurance provider will ask to see.

  • Core
  • Intermediate
  • about 15 hours

Part of the ESG analyst roadmap: from the basics to mid level

Written by the GreenHired editorial teamSources last checked 20 November 2026How we research roadmaps

A materiality assessment is a sequence with a paper trail. Build a long list, map who is affected, score each topic on each lens separately, fix the thresholds before you look at the results so nobody tunes them, then record who signed off. EFRAG’s guide illustrates four steps (context, identify, assess, report) but does not mandate one process. The order and the record matter more than the labels.

Does water use make the cut?

An invented food manufacturer has a plant in a water-stressed area, and the topic to score is water use. Every number and threshold below is made up for the example, and the ESRS set no fixed threshold.

On the impact lens the team scores scale 4, scope 3 and irremediable character 2, each out of 5. Its own rule is to average them: (4 + 3 + 2) / 3 = 3.0, and a topic passes at 3.0 or more. The plant is already drawing the water, so this is an actual impact and the example skips likelihood. For a potential impact you would score likelihood as well.

On the financial lens, finance estimates that a supply cut could cost GBP 400,000 a year. The threshold agreed with finance is GBP 500,000, so water fails this lens.

The result is material on the impact lens only. Under double materiality that is enough, and the record says which lens carried it. One blended score would have averaged a pass and a fail into a middling number, and the topic might have been dropped.

The folder behind the method note

The method note is the page an assurance provider will ask to see. It lists where the long list came from (a GRI topic list or the SASB industry finder, for example), who was consulted and how, the scoring rules, the thresholds with their dates, the topics screened out with reasons, and the approver. Keep the survey data and meeting notes behind it. How the result feeds a report is covered in CSRD and the ESRS, and how it reaches other frameworks in framework mapping and gap analysis.

Plan the refresh now: next year starts from this folder and changes only what the business changed. IG 1 was written for the 2023 ESRS, and the simplified ESRS adopted on 3 July 2026 amend that text. As read on 20 November 2026, check EFRAG and the Commission for current guidance before you copy a method.

What you will learn

  • Explain impact materiality and financial materiality and why the ESRS ask for both
  • Run the four steps of EFRAG's illustrative process: context, identify, assess, report
  • Score impacts by severity (scale, scope, irremediable character) and likelihood, and risks by anticipated financial effect
  • Map affected stakeholders and design engagement that produces usable evidence
  • Use GRI 3 and the SASB industry lens as starting points for a long list
  • Write the methodology note, record thresholds and get sign-off, then plan the annual refresh

The parts of this topic

Impact and financial materialityabout 3 hours

One lens asks how the company affects people and the environment; the other asks how sustainability matters affect the company's finances.

EFRAG's guidance says an undertaking applying the ESRS is expected to comply with the identification of risk and opportunity information under the ISSB standards, so the financial lens lines up with ISSB. The impact lens looks outward at people and nature. Under double materiality a topic is material if it passes either lens: it can matter to society and not to profit, or the reverse. Keep a separate score for each lens, or you lose the reason a topic was chosen: a plant's water use, for instance, may pass the impact lens only.

GRI 3: determining material topicsabout 3 hours

GRI's standard for choosing the topics an organisation reports on, published in 2021 and effective for reporting from 2023.

GRI 3: Material Topics 2021 was published on 5 October 2021 and, with GRI 1 and GRI 2, forms the Universal Standards that came into effect for reporting on 1 January 2023. GRI's list of topic standards is not the answer: run the process and record why topics were included or left out. EFRAG's guidance says an assessment done under the GRI Universal Standards is a good basis for the impact assessment under the ESRS, so the work is reusable; a GRI 3 long list can be the first draft of the ESRS impact list.

  • GRI: The GRI Standards Global Reporting Initiative · Standard Universal Standards effective 1 January 2023; free to download

ESRS impacts, risks, opportunities and thresholdsabout 3 hours

The ESRS ask you to identify impacts, risks and opportunities, then set your own thresholds; there is no fixed cut-off.

EFRAG's guidance says severity rests on scale, scope and irremediable character for negative impacts, and on scale and scope for positive ones, assessed with likelihood. Risks and opportunities are assessed against thresholds for anticipated financial effect. ESRS 1 sets criteria but not specific thresholds, so your team must choose and document them: write down why your threshold sits where it does, because another company's threshold, copied without reasons, gives you nothing to say when asked. Disclosures then cover the process (IRO-1), its link to strategy (SBM-3) and the list of requirements covered (IRO-2).

Stakeholder mapping and engagementabout 2 hours

Identify who is affected, ask them in a way that yields evidence, and record what you did with the answers.

EFRAG's guidance says engagement with affected stakeholders informs the assessment and supports the importance of a topic from their point of view, but the ESRS do not mandate specific behaviour. Start with a map of affected groups across activities and the value chain, then choose methods such as interviews, surveys or workshops. For a factory, include the neighbouring community and contract workers, not only managers. A survey of people who are easy to reach is not stakeholder views. AccountAbility's AA1000 standards on stakeholder engagement and on assurance are a reference for method.

  • AccountAbility: AA1000 standards AccountAbility · Standard Stakeholder Engagement Standard and Assurance Standard; the page did not state whether downloads are free

SASB industry lens for financial topicsabout 2 hours

SASB Standards give a starting list of financially relevant topics by industry, which feeds the financial side of the assessment.

The IFRS introduction page says IFRS S1 requires a company to consider SASB disclosure topics when it looks for industry-specific risks and opportunities. The SASB navigator has a Materiality Finder and a link to find your industry. Use the finder to draft the industry's usual topics before you speak to anyone, then test them against your own business: drop a listed topic you do not operate, with a written reason. Some navigator features appear to be premium, so check what is free before you plan around it.

Documentation, sign-off and annual refreshabout 2 hours

A materiality result is only as good as its record: method, thresholds, evidence, approvers and the plan to revisit it.

EFRAG's guidance lists what must be disclosed after the assessment: the process, how material items interact with strategy and the requirements covered. Without the record you redo the assessment from scratch, so keep the long list, scoring sheets, survey data, threshold logic, meeting notes and approval in one versioned folder. COSO's 2023 guidance applies its internal control framework to sustainability reporting and helps you treat the assessment as a controlled process. Next year's refresh then starts from that folder and changes only what the business changed.

Practice task

Run a small materiality assessment for an invented mid-sized manufacturer: a long list of about 15 topics, a stakeholder map, a scoring sheet with stated thresholds for impacts and for financial effects, a short list with reasons, and a one-page methodology note that shows who signed it off and when it will be refreshed.

Skills you build

Materiality assessmentStakeholder engagementImpact severity scoringThreshold settingMethodology documentation

Resources for this topic

Every source here is free. Each link opens the provider's own site in a new tab.

Back to the whole roadmap

Live jobs

Jobs related to ESG analyst

No title matches the role itself right now, so these are live jobs in the same field.

All ESG & Sustainability Reporting jobs

Spot a problem with this topic?

Tell us what is wrong, missing or unclear here. Your note is attached to this topic.

Notes are sent from this page with JavaScript on. Without it, write to us on the contact page.