Stage 9: Reporting and communication · topic 34 of 47

Green claims and greenwashing risk

Environmental claims such as 'carbon neutral' or 'eco-friendly' are regulated in the UK, EU, US and India. You will test a claim against its evidence, reword it, and keep a register so every claim has an owner and a check date.

  • Optional
  • Intermediate
  • about 8 hours

Part of the ESG analyst roadmap: from the basics to mid level

Written by the GreenHired editorial teamSources last checked 20 November 2026How we research roadmaps

Who owns this claim, and which file proves it? Like a number in a report, every environmental claim needs an owner, a file and a date when it is checked again. Work from the exact words on the page back to the evidence, never the other way round. Your job is to ask for the evidence and suggest wording that fits it. Legal decides what is published, and this page is not legal advice.

‘Carbon neutral delivery’ at a tea shop checkout

An imaginary tea shop, with invented details, shows ‘Carbon neutral delivery’ at checkout.

What does it cover? Only the courier’s last leg. Packaging and the warehouse are outside it. A claim about the whole service that covers one part is what the EU blacklist targets, and the CMA’s full life cycle principle asks the same question.

What is the basis? The shop buys offset credits and has cut nothing. UK advertising guidance says to explain the basis and say whether it is offsetting. The EU blacklist bans offset-based claims that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive impact.

Is the evidence current? The credit certificate is for 2024 deliveries and the claim is live in 2026, so it is stale.

Who decides? The claim is absolute, offset-based and aimed at consumers: three of the four escalation triggers in the claims register part. It goes to legal.

A suggested rewrite for legal to judge: “We offset the emissions of courier delivery for 2025 with certified credits. Packaging and warehousing are not included.” In some EU markets legal may say to drop the claim entirely. Log the claim, the evidence and the decision either way. Report wording is covered in writing the report.

The rules differ by market

As read on 20 November 2026, and always to be checked on the regulator’s own pages:

  • UK: the Green Claims Code (six principles, a 13-point checklist) and ASA and CAP guidance.
  • EU: Directive (EU) 2024/825, applied from 27 September 2026 according to the Commission’s page. Check your national law.
  • EU Green Claims proposal: the Commission’s page still showed “Pending”. A law-firm note of 5 November 2026 (Loyens & Loeff) reports that the Commission’s 2027 work programme, published on 4 November 2026, lists the proposal for withdrawal, and that it stays formally pending until the withdrawal is completed. The work programme was not opened for this page, so check the Commission directly.
  • US and India: the FTC Green Guides and India’s 2024 CCPA guidelines.

Targets and ratings are claims too

“Science-based” or “rated A” in a report is a claim with the same needs, and climate risk, targets and transition plans explains the SBTi versions. The SBTi page says version 1.3.1 stays the applicable version for validation throughout 2026 and Version 2.0 is published, so state which one the target was validated under.

What you will learn

  • Name the six principles of the UK Green Claims Code and the evidence each one expects.
  • Say what the EU rules that apply from 27 September 2026 mean for generic claims, labels and offset-based claims.
  • Explain why 'carbon neutral' and 'net zero' need a stated basis, and tell offsets from real reductions.
  • Describe how regulators in the US and India approach the same problem.
  • Keep a claims register and know when to escalate to legal.

The parts of this topic

Evidence for every claimabout 2 hours

Hold current, credible evidence before a claim goes out, and make the claim say no more than the evidence shows.

The UK CMA's Green Claims Code has six principles: claims must be truthful and accurate, clear and unambiguous, not omit or hide important information, make fair and meaningful comparisons, consider the full life cycle, and be substantiated. Its guidance gives an example of a shampoo bar sold as 'eco shampoo' that was judged misleading because the label implied an overall benefit the product did not have. Check that your evidence is current and covers the whole product, not one part of it.

Generic and absolute claimsabout 1 hour

Understand why words like 'green' or 'eco-friendly' are risky unless you can show excellent environmental performance.

The EU directive adds to the EU blacklist of unfair practices: making a generic environmental claim when the trader cannot demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance relevant to the claim, and presenting a claim about a whole product or business when it covers only one aspect. Member States had to apply their national rules from 27 September 2026, and the Commission's page says the directive entered into application on that date. A typical case is 'eco-friendly' in a website header that nobody ever tested against the product. Check your own country's law.

Offsets, 'carbon neutral' and net zeroabout 1 hour

Say clearly whether a claim rests on cutting emissions or on offsets, and never imply a product has no emissions when it does.

UK advertising guidance advises avoiding unqualified 'carbon neutral' and 'net zero' claims, explaining the basis, saying whether the claim relies on offsetting or on reductions, and backing future goals with a verifiable strategy. The ASA upheld complaints about a carbon neutral business claim (Charles Tyrwhitt, December 2023) and a carbon negative claim (BrewDog, December 2023). In the EU, the same blacklist also bans claims, based on offsetting, that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive impact. If you do rely on offsets, ask about the quality of the credits: the ICVCM principles in the resources are one yardstick.

Labels, seals and ratingsabout 1 hour

Check what stands behind a logo, a certification or a rating before you show it next to a claim.

The same EU directive also blacklists displaying a sustainability label that is not based on a certification scheme or established by public authorities. Typical trouble spots are a self-made leaf badge that looks like an independent label and a rating quoted without saying who awarded it and when. In the US, the FTC's Green Guides, first issued in 1992 and last revised in 2012, cover certifications and seals of approval, renewable claims and carbon offset claims, and the FTC has taken action against marketers in several cases.

  • FTC Green Guides US Federal Trade Commission · Guide The page says the FTC sought comment in 2022-2023 on possible updates

Claims made across a supply chainabout 1 hour

Know that brands, retailers and suppliers each share responsibility for a claim that travels down the chain.

In January 2026 the CMA published guidance on getting green claims right across the supply chain, stating that retailers, brands, and manufacturers or suppliers share responsibility for making sure claims are not misleading. For an analyst this means a supplier's certificate, or a customer's request for 'recycled' wording, becomes your claim once you repeat it. The date, the scope and the product a supplier statement covers are what to check before passing it on.

India and other regionsabout 1 hour

Know that India has its own greenwashing guidelines and that the rules differ by market, so check where the claim will be seen.

India's consumer authority (CCPA) lists 'Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Greenwashing or Misleading Environmental Claims, 2024' on its guidelines page. The PDF is a scanned image, read by eye on 20 November 2026. It says generic terms such as 'green', 'eco-friendly' or 'carbon-neutral' need adequate qualifiers and substantiation, that claims need accessible, verifiable evidence from independent studies or third-party certification, and that material information must be disclosed, for example through a QR code or URL. Read the scan yourself before relying on it, and check each market where a claim will appear.

Practice task

Pick a public company's sustainability web page, list ten environmental claims on it, and test each against the 13-point UK Green Claims Code checklist. Write a one-page table with the claim, the evidence you could find, a pass or fail and the rewording you would suggest.

Skills you build

Claim substantiationConsumer-law awarenessNet-zero wordingClaims registerLegal escalation

Resources for this topic

Every source here is free. Each link opens the provider's own site in a new tab.

Back to the whole roadmap

Live jobs

Jobs related to ESG analyst

No title matches the role itself right now, so these are live jobs in the same field.

All ESG & Sustainability Reporting jobs

Spot a problem with this topic?

Tell us what is wrong, missing or unclear here. Your note is attached to this topic.

Notes are sent from this page with JavaScript on. Without it, write to us on the contact page.