Stage 8: Ratings, investors, sustainable finance · topic 30 of 47

ESG ratings, EcoVadis and customer questionnaires

ESG ratings are model outputs, and questionnaires ask for evidence. You will see why raters disagree and answer EcoVadis, CDP and customer requests from one evidence library and an answer bank.

  • Core
  • Intermediate
  • about 15 hours

Part of the ESG analyst roadmap: from the basics to mid level

Written by the GreenHired editorial teamSources last checked 20 November 2026How we research roadmaps

Every rating and questionnaire is a reporting task with an owner and a deadline, not a form. Build an evidence library and an answer bank once, answer from them every time, and keep a calendar of scored windows. Then you can explain any score in a paragraph and correct a rater’s factual error with one document.

When two customers get two Scope 2 numbers

An invented supplier gets two customer questionnaires in the same month. Both ask for last year’s Scope 2 emissions. Different people answer: one sends 4,200 tonnes CO2e, the other 3,900. The numbers are made up.

Assume both are right: 4,200 is the location-based figure and 3,900 the market-based one, a difference of 300 tonnes (300 / 4,200 = 7.1%). But neither customer was told which was which, and a buyer who later sees both in a supplier database will ask why they differ.

The fix is an answer bank entry: the question (“Scope 2 emissions last year”), the approved answer with both figures labelled and the boundary stated, the source file, the approver and the date. Next time, you copy the entry. If the question is new, its owner drafts the answer and the entry is added to the bank. The evidence comes from the cycle in data collection and controls.

The same library lets you challenge a rater. If a report says the company has no anti-corruption policy, send a short note naming the item, the policy document and the page, rather than an argument about methodology. For the law on rating providers see EU: Taxonomy, SFDR and ESG-rating rules, and for India’s rules India: BRSR and CCTS.

Across the 16 job postings we sampled (UK, EU, US and India; how we research roadmaps), 4 involved ESG ratings submissions, 3 named CDP and 2 named EcoVadis, so an answer bank is a skill to show.

Read a score as the answer to one question

MSCI’s page describes ESG Ratings as an assessment of a company’s resilience to financially relevant, industry-specific sustainability risks, expressed as an industry-relative letter grade from AAA to CCC. Morningstar Sustainalytics describes ESG Risk Ratings as an assessment of exposure to industry-specific material ESG risks and how well they are managed, in five severity levels from negligible to severe.

These answer different questions, so two scores need not agree, and the research in the parts below suggests most disagreement comes from measurement and scope. ISS and S&P Global’s Corporate Sustainability Assessment are also common, but this page does not describe their methods.

What you will learn

  • Describe what MSCI and Sustainalytics ratings measure and how their scales differ
  • Explain why ratings from different providers disagree for the same company
  • Answer EcoVadis, CDP and customer questionnaires from an evidence library rather than from memory
  • Understand CDP scoring rules and what happens when a response is not submitted on time
  • Challenge a factual error with a rater politely and with proof
  • Know the main rules on rating providers in the EU and India

The parts of this topic

Why ratings disagreeabout 3 hours

Researchers found that disagreement between raters comes mostly from how they measure and what they include, not from the weights.

Berg, Kölbel and Rigobon studied six major rating providers in a paper in the Review of Finance (volume 26, issue 6, November 2022). They split the divergence into measurement (56%), scope (38%) and weight (6%), and found a rater effect, in which a rater's overall view of a firm influences how it measures specific categories. Practical consequence: do not expect two raters to agree, and do not chase one score. Treat a rating as one model's output about the company, not as a fact about it.

EcoVadis and customer questionnairesabout 3 hours

Supplier assessments and customer questionnaires ask for policies, actions and results, with evidence attached.

EcoVadis presents its rating as an independent view of a company's sustainability performance and says the service is used across 180+ countries and 230+ industries. Treat each questionnaire as a mini-project: a named owner, a deadline, an evidence folder and an answer bank. When each customer gets a freshly worded answer, no two numbers agree later, so answer from the bank and update the bank when a question is new.

CDP responses and scoresabout 3 hours

A CDP score only exists if you submit on time; learn the deadline and appeal rules, then the scoring methodology.

CDP's score page says companies that did not respond by the scoring deadline do not receive a score, and that listed scores are final although some may change while appeals are open. The page did not describe the scale or levels when read on 20 November 2026, so open the CDP scoring methodology from the site to learn them. Plan the year around the questionnaire window, reuse your report data and record each answer's source. A company that misses the deadline gets no score, however good its data.

  • CDP: Scores CDP · Guide Score rules and appeals; the lists on the page load dynamically

Evidence library and correcting rater errorsabout 3 hours

A well-organised library of documents and data lets you answer fast and correct a rater's factual error with proof.

The GHG Protocol Corporate Standard stresses that clear, well-documented methods and data are especially important to an inventory's credibility, and the same holds for rating responses. Build a library with policies, certificates, data tables, audited figures and dates, tagged by topic. When a rater has something factually wrong, send a short note naming the item, the evidence and the page. Correct facts; do not argue with opinions. If the rater says no anti-corruption policy exists, send the page of your code of conduct that contains it.

Rules for rating providers: EU and Indiaabout 3 hours

The EU and India now regulate ESG ratings, which changes how providers document methods and how rated companies can engage.

In the EU, Regulation 2024/3005 applies from 2 July 2026 and requires providers serving investors and companies in the EU to be authorised and supervised by ESMA, with disclosure duties towards the public and towards users and rated entities. In India, SEBI's FAQ defines ESG ratings to include rule-based and algorithmic scores and requires overseas providers that rate Indian asset classes for Indian clients to register through a local entity. Before you cite a rating as evidence, check that its provider is authorised where you use it.

Practice task

Build a rating response pack for an invented company: an evidence library mapped to twenty typical questions with an owner and date for each, an answer bank, a comparison of two public rating methods (what each measures, its scale and what it rewards), and a draft correction letter to a rater with evidence attached.

Skills you build

ESG rating methodsQuestionnaire responsesEvidence librariesRater engagementRating regulation awareness

Resources for this topic

Every source here is free. Each link opens the provider's own site in a new tab.

  • MSCI: ESG Ratings MSCI · Guide Public product page; the full methodology is a separate document it links to
  • Morningstar Sustainalytics: ESG Risk Ratings Morningstar Sustainalytics · Guide Public overview of the five-level risk scale
  • CDP CDP · Tool Disclosure system covering climate, forests and water
  • SASB navigator IFRS Foundation · Tool Industry standards that help you see which issues are specific to your sector; some features appear to be premium

Back to the whole roadmap

Live jobs

Jobs related to ESG analyst

No title matches the role itself right now, so these are live jobs in the same field.

All ESG & Sustainability Reporting jobs

Spot a problem with this topic?

Tell us what is wrong, missing or unclear here. Your note is attached to this topic.

Notes are sent from this page with JavaScript on. Without it, write to us on the contact page.